Tuesday, January 18, 2011

The Power of Formal Prayer


Guest post by Isaac Fox

Recently I posted a short essay on ecumenism and the Sign of the Cross entitled In Nomine Patris. In that essay I particularly tried to demonstrate that the Catholic practice of making the Sign of the Cross should not be found offensive to non-Catholics; that it was, in fact, a very good practice; and that it might serve as an example of a practice that could be adopted by Christian of many traditions with the purpose of both personal enrichment, and Christian unity. I also suggested the study of Sacred Scripture as an excellent practice often found in Protestant circles that could and should be more widely adopted by Catholics. Today I would like to continue in a similar vein, on another Catholic practice that I believe could greatly enrich the lives of all Christians, put us back in touch with long-abandoned Tradition, and also be very effective in restoring unity among Christians. I am referring to formal prayer.


*       *       *

Comment here, or at Isaac Fox's website.

Monday, January 17, 2011

Paul Craig Roberts Talks About Animal Rights

       I really appreciate Paul Craig Roberts.  He was a part of the Reagan Revolution that I admire.  As an advocate of (the much derided, but nevertheless appropriate) supply-side economics, he helped to establish the success of Reaganomics.  (With the help also of Paul Volcker, a more responsible head of the Federal Reserve than his recent successors.)

       Roberts saw, first-hand as Assistant Secretary of the Treasury, the embedded greed of the Republican establishment, most particularly in its congressional and Wall Street manifestations, as it inentionally and vigorously hobbled and weakened the original Reagan vision of limited government and fiscal responsibility.

       He also saw, as did Joe Sobran and others, the foreign policy distortions that occurred as the so-called "neo-conservatives"  (actually neo-Trotskyites)  insinuated themselves into the foreign policy apparatus, effecting a general takeover by the time of the H. W. Bush Administration, but overly influential long before (read: Iran-contra).

       When, after the September 11 Incident and Cover-Up, I began to pay more attention again to what was happening -- I never well-understood the Clinton Years, and still don't -- Mr. Roberts was on hand with reliable insight:  he had never lost track.  I respect everything he says.

       Which brings me right up to the present.  He has an article about  . . . animal rights!  (And he's for them!)   I love it when older writers (he's past seventy now) loosen up and tell you things that have been growing in the backs of their minds for a while.

       Enjoy his article, "A Brief for Animals," here.

*       *       *

       I highly recommend his book, Tyranny of Good Intentions.  Everyone who loves his country should read this.  Including non-Americans who love their countries.

       Agreeable (and horrified!) comments always welcome!

  

Thursday, January 13, 2011

The Torch With No Oil

       I have long been an advocate of full "Second Amendment Rights," and have no plans to change my mind.  The Second Amendment to the Constitution of the United States rather famously states that "the right of the People to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed," and I am quite satisfied with the intentions and language of the Framers.  I am glad that this is a part of the supreme law of the land.

       I recall a short documentary made by Charlton Heston several years ago, when he was president of the National Rifle Association and a prominent advocate of the Second Amendment.   Called "A Torch With No Flame," he warns that a freedom, in this case private individual gun-ownership, is probably not going to survive a generation of voters who do not understand it, and therefore do not value it properly.  In the video, it is clear that Heston knows that he is nearing the end of his life, and he is, or is becoming, very concerned.  I think I agree with him.

       May I offer a similar concern to "Tea Party" constitutionalists?

       I am glad that you are re-discovering your "constitutional rights" and are standing up for them.

       I applaud your discovery, or re-discovery, of the Constitution.  As the final expression (at least so far) of what is often called the "organic law" of the United States, it does speak to many Americans on a level so deep that one might almost call it spiritual.

       When you are having an important political conversation with someone with whom you disagree, whether left-wing, right-wing, or otherwise -- have you experienced inward relief, as I have, when you find that your opponent really believes in the Constitution?  Relief, because you know that whatever differences you may have, you have very, very much in common.

       But much depends upon those words, "real belief."  I think we all realize that waving a flag, or even pledging allegiance to it, or even calling yourself a "patriotic American," does not make you a patriotic American.  In like manner,  waving a Constitution, or taking an oath to protect it, or "standing up for your constitutional rights," does not make you a constitutionalist.

       May I suggest that what decides the question is whether you deeply and really believe that what it says is good and true.  That it gives a good description of what is, and what should be.

       It might be good to set aside a couple of hours of your time, sit down with nothing but the Constitution and a notepad and pen for jotting down your thoughts and questions, and start reading.  I'd suggest starting with the Bill of Rights (the first ten Amendments), as they, along with the Preamble, provide the framework by which the entire document is to be understood.

       Here are some questions that I ask myself.

       Do I really believe in freedom of speech, and of the press?  
       What does the Constitution really say about religion?
       What are cruel and unusual punishments?
       How important is a fair trial?
       What is bail, and what is excessive bail?
       Is there anything that the government is doing that is illegal?
       What is the function of political parties?
       What is a bill of attainder, corruption of blood, or title of nobility, and why does the Constitution forbid or severely regulate them?
       What is habeas corpus, and why and how is it talked about?
       What is an ex post facto law?
       What is treason?
    
       And of course, there are many more important questions.

       I am no one's judge.  But I suspect that some people's loyalty to the Constitution is quite shallow.  Please don't misunderstand; I am glad for even shallow loyalty these days, because the Constitution is an almost universally disregarded document in our federal and state governments, in the media, and in most folks' minds.  If you seriously care about the Constitution at all, you and I are in a minority group that is probably less than 20% of the total population of the United States of America.  (I hope I am wrong about this.)

       But today -- and always -- the Constitution needs defenders and advocates who know and believe what it says at a deep level of integrity.

       I am afraid that we have self-styled "constitutionalists" today who think they can reconcile the Constitution with torture, with imprisonment without jury trial, with confiscatory anti-drug laws, with federally mandated smoking restrictions, with mandated health-care, with phony money, with a welfare state, with a warfare state, with a police state, with heavy-handed treatment of "illegal aliens," "domestic terrorists,"  "security risks," "people who look like they are middle eastern," people who board airplanes, and so on.

       This kind of thinking may be sincere, but it is sloppy thinking that will probably do more harm than good.  It produces, in Thomas Paine's words, "summer soldiers" and "sunshine patriots."   Not good when the weather turns bad.  When some new media-manufactured fad, or government-manufactured crisis blows through.

       Lacking depth, their convictions will sputter into smoky confusion.  Like a torch with no oil.  Standing up for their own constitutional rights, but unaware of their roots in the natural and moral law, are they going to ignore their responsibility to stand for the precisely equal constitutional rights of us all?

       May it not be so.

*       *       *

       Comments pro and con always welcome.  This topic urgently needs to be discussed; please take part.

      

  

Wednesday, January 12, 2011

Towards a Moral Economy

Guest post by Isaac Fox

Morality and Economics. Those are two words that we seldom see juxtaposed in  print. And I suspect that we seldom associate them in our own minds. We hear a lot about the economy these days. "The economy is up"; "The economy is down"; "We're in a recession"; "Maybe the economy needs another stimulus package"; and on and on we go. Our chief concern with the economy seems to be only how much wealth is presently flowing towards us. In fact, that seems to be as far as our definition and understanding of economy goes. A good economy means that I am making more money at the moment. "Good" has no specially moral value in the above sentence. Perhaps we might feel an occasional self-righteous hint of moral repugnance at the size of the National Debt, or the disparity between the rich and the poor in America, but beyond that morality remains largely unconnected in our minds with the economy. Yet economic structures contain all the necessary ingredients for moral culpability or virtue, and demand moral thought and action from us, as much as government, environmentalism, politics, business, and our inter-personal relationships do. When we leave morality out of politics, business, relationships, etc... well, I probably don't need to finish that sentence--we've all seen where it goes.



Let's glance at morality for just a moment. Morality has to do with relationship. Relationship is implied in every moral action. To see this, let's take an extreme (and impossible) hypothetical example. Suppose that nothing existed except you. No God, no universe, no people, and no possibility of anything else ever coming to exist. There is no law for you to break, there are no persons for you to hurt, and no God for you to offend. Without relationship to a law, or God, or nature, or other persons, your actions will have no moral significance. Morality enters the scene the moment a relationship is established.



Now, hold that thought for a second, and let's go back to economics. The first part of the Merriam-Webster College Dictionary's definition of economics reads as follows: "The social science that deals with the production, distribution, and consumption of goods and services...." Through this definition we can see that economics deals with very relational topics. Production involves labor, or work. Distribution involves buying, selling and shipping. Or to put it more simply: trade. So economics involves  work, trade, and consumption. Now it is almost self-evident that these three subjects are fundamentally relational and moral.

Tuesday, January 11, 2011

The CIA War in Pakistan

       I thought of a long lead-in to this post, but I think I'll just mention a few facts and then conclude with a personal opinion.

       Fact.   It is reported -- I believe reliably -- that CIA drone strikes in Pakistan have killed over 1600 tribesmen in Pakistan since President Obama took office.  (In the last three years of the George Bush administration, over 400 were killed in the drone wars, which brings the total above 2,000.)  Drones, in this case, are unmanned aircraft that are loaded with explosives and remotely controlled by operators in front of computer screens at a command center.

       Fact.  The target area is in what Pakistan calls its "Federally Administered Tribal Area."  This area is in Pakistan as a result of convenient boundary-drawing during the heyday of the British Empire (as are many of the other borders in the Middle East and Southern Asia).  These boundaries did not reflect the homelands of different nations or ethnic units, but served the administrative and geo-political objectives of foreign intruders and overlords.  This target area is occupied mostly by the Pashtun and other mountain tribespeople, who are not especially distinguishable from their Pashtun brethren on the Afghan side of the border.

        Fact.  I am told -- I believe reliably -- that for centuries the Pashtun mountain people have not liked, and have in fact quite actively and successfully resisted, the civilization that is centered in the valley cities of Pakistan.  Pakistan therefore has a very limited ability to control what goes on in this area; and what with other stresses in Pakistan these days, the central government has very little stomach for "pacifying" the Pashtun, regardless of the US Government's insistence that they do so.

       Fact.  Since the world's earliest memory, the mountain regions of Afghanistan-Pakistan have been populated by a very independent and (it seems to me, at least) fierce people.  They did not learn these ways, nor did they change their essential behaviors, because of the Prophet, or British missionaries, or Soviet troops, or any other form of foreign influence.  (Opinion:  These tribespeople cannot possibly have anything to do with "threatening our freedoms."  Further opinion:  Since a real war must have a real reason, and the stated reason cannot be real, the real reason must be something else.  I wonder what it is.)

       Fact.  I am informed -- I believe reliably -- that these tribesmen, and others, have grown opium for uncounted generations.  They not only use it for their own pleasure and medicine, but have been known to sell it to outsiders for a long, long time.  I am further informed that among their most eager customers have been (for a couple of centuries) prominent British (and later American) merchandising families.  These specially gifted and anointed families like to establish -- um, shall we say "vertical monopolies" (control the production at the source) -- utilizing "security services" (public or private mercenaries) in order to um, "assure market stability with a view to long-term profit maximization."

       Fact.  These British families (and later American) were tightly linked to the military and security apparatus of the British Empire, and there is no way of saying where one begins and the other ends.  The colonial arrangements evolved directly into the "modern" global intelligence and security arrangements and functionaries of the 20th century and today. A direct descent can be traced to British MI5 and to the American OSS and its successor organization, the CIA.

       Fact.  Favored British and American families have been prominently involved in drug trafficking. They find it most convenient to make drugs "illegal" so they can control the entry points, control the traffic, control the judicial system, and hopefully eliminate competition.  You can research this easily on the Internet by searching with keywords which will occur to you.

       Many More Facts.  Follow your curiosity and see where it leads.  (Hint.  It leads beyond Internet "conspiracy theory" to books written by solid historians.)

       *       *       *

       Now for a bit of personal opinion.  Purely personal opinion, mind you.

       I hate to hear about people being stoned to death, whether it is by mob violence or culturally sanctioned for crimes.  Yes, I know that for a long time Middle Eastern cultures both Jewish and Islamic have found religious justification for this custom.  Often, they can plausibly appeal to God for approval of their actions -- though I observe that Saul of Tarsus was neither the first nor the last person who sanctioned a stoning only to find out later that the Divine Will was quite opposite to his own.

       I can surf the net and quickly find accounts of girls being stoned -- in such countries as Somalia, Kurdistan, and Pakistan -- for crimes ranging from adultery, to having been raped by a family member, to walking in public with a male fellow religionist.  The reporters of these events purport to be horrified, as I am.  As, I think, you are.  They decry the action and variously blame the Taliban, Islam, or "the insane elements in society."  Anyway, they blame people who are not us.

       If I am horrified at the sight, or the thought, of a young girl being stoned for violating a cultural norm . . . I am also horrified when I learn that the CIA persistently use drone aircraft to target assemblies of civilians in Afghanistan and Pakistan, including girls on the way to their own weddings, blowing them into wounded or dead fragments of themselves, stoned by chunks of metal instead of chunks of rock.

       These drone aircraft are authorized by Congress, paid for by American taxpayers and bankers, built by war profiteers, and operated by the CIA from remote bases and safe places staffed by young military personnel whose understanding of the morality of war comes chiefly from whatever they learned while playing computer games.  These young people will be among the veterans that we will honor in our American civic religion in five years time.  None of these people are Taliban; they are not Muslim.  They may or may not be "the insane elements in society"; but they are us.

       Alternatively we are told that (a) we aren't doing it  (b) we are investigating it  (c) we will see to it that it will never happen again (d) it is unavoidable (e) we are winning hearts and minds (f) it is Hamid Karzai's fault that we are not winning hearts and minds; (g,h,i,j).

       If the commanding general of the American forces had a strong conscience, he could order the CIA to cease and desist in his area of operations.  If they failed to comply, that would be very telling;  we would then know who is really in charge.  In that case he could resign his command, as the American General John Wool did when he was ordered by the Department of War to oversee the Cherokee Removal in 1838.

       If the American president had a strong conscience, he could shut down the entire war enterprise in southwest Asia, on his own authority as commander-in-chief.  If the War Party in the US Congress threatened to impeach him, which they probably would, we could all see how numerous they are; and we could also learn a lot from each other about how we all really think.

      The President, following his conscience, could then resign and turn the whole bloody mess over to the vice-president, who could then decide what he wanted to do -- maybe resign himself and turn it over to the new Speaker of the House, who would then become president and put this sordid affair back in the hands of the neo-conservative Republicans who have been the biggest cheerleaders of this war.  Then they could elect Dick Cheney in 2012.

       I'm sure I have left out important facts and considerations.  Your comments always welcome, pro and con.

Thursday, January 6, 2011

The Sacraments of Middle Earth

Guest post by Isaac Fox

"...those who have dwelt in the Blessed Realm live at once in both worlds, and against both the Seen and the Unseen they have great power." "Yes, you saw him for a moment as he is upon the other side: one of the mighty of the Firstborn." Thus Tolkien has Gandalf describe the Elf-lord Glorfindel in The Fellowship of the Ring. 

I have long suspected J.R.R. Tolkien of being one who lived in both worlds at once. Witness his keen perception of and appreciation for both physical and spiritual realities. But I think that this is a common trait that is (or should be) shared by all Christians. And if  I may say this without being seen as indulging in some divisive prejudice, I find that this is especially observable in the Catholic Church. The Mass is seen as heaven on earth, the realities of the spiritual world intersecting and mingling with the clear realities of time and space. During the Sanctus we are called upon to realize that our voices singing "Holy, Holy, Holy" are truly joined with the voices of the angels as they sing in another realm. We are made to realize that we are living "at once in both worlds." And perhaps this is nowhere more true than in the Sacraments, those great mysteries of our Faith. We see the material reality of water poured out upon one's head, as Grace is simultaneously poured out into one's soul. A person can smell the incensed "oil of gladness", and  feel it upon upon one's hair and skin, as one is confirmed interiorly in Holy Spirit. We know that the Priest that absolves or consecrates is simply a stand-in; it is Christ absolving, Christ consecrating. And most of all, we may hopefully come to see our Lord hidden under the appearance of bread and wine.

What does all of this have to do with Tolkien and The Lord of the Rings? Simply this: I believe that Tolkien's works are fundamentally sacramental. I believe that a sacramental understanding underlies and breathes through page after page of Tolkien's works. It is easy to go to extremes in reading him. We may be tempted to deny any hint of allegory, since the author denied that his works were allegorical. But remember, he was insisting upon this in response to the idea that one of his chapters was meant to be an allegory of post-WWII England ("The Scouring of the Shire"). After all, in another place, Tolkien says that the books were "at first unconsciously, then later consciously Christian, and specifically Catholic." (Take the quotes loosely here, I'm quoting from memory, but I think it's fairly close.)  It is also possible to go to the other extreme and read too much into Tolkien's intentions and make the books strictly allegorical. But I do not think that it would  be wrong to recognize the underlying sacramentalism in the Trilogy.

I was deeply attracted to The Lord of the Rings as a boy, but for years I knew nothing about the author.



*       *       *

Comments always welcome .  Here; or better yet, with Isaac himself.


Tuesday, January 4, 2011

State-Based Propaganda -- An Old Case History

       A couple of years ago I read an old story in the Bible and caught an entirely fresh sense of its significance.  It was the historical account of Israel's ill-advised war on Syria as recorded in the Second Book of the Chronicles, Chapter Eighteen.  The story includes details of the activities of evil kings, allies, war councils, soldiers, the misguided pious, prophets, assemblies of ruling spirits, and the opinions of God Himself.

       Since I had never before seen the connections between this ancient record and current events in the Middle East, I immediately wanted to get the idea down in a lecture form -- or more recently, in the form of a lengthy post here.

       I am happy to report that that is not necessary.  Andrew Hoffman has done an excellent job in the post that begins below. -- Robert Heid


State Propaganda vs. A Prophet

by Andrew Hoffman

First of all, I know you’re probably thinking “another 2 Chronicles 18 post, how cliché!” I promise to cover something original, like Romans 13, sometime soon.
In this chapter, King Jehoshaphat of Judah goes to meet with King Ahab of Israel. After buttering him up by killing a bunch of sheep and oxen, Ahab asks Jehoshaphat to go to war with him against Ramoth Gilead. In modern PR parlance, Ahab was using the Law of Reciprocation to create a feeling of indebtedness in Jehoshaphat. It is the same technique used by the Hare Krishna’s in the 1960’s—giving someone a small gift before asking for something much more valuable in return.


Read the rest of the article here.
Andrew Hoffman is an independent writer and researcher.  He is the author of the book, The New World Order and the Eugenics Wars: A Christian Perspective.  Visit him at his websites here and here.    As always, comments welcome, pro and con.